A Modest Proposal For The Current Flag Controversy

Here is a sensible solution to the flag brouhaha that has erupted following the Charleston Massacre of 2015. Textile artist Sonya Clark has partially unraveled the controversial confederate flag (lower case intentional to convey punctuational contempt) so that the unraveled threads appear to be blood streaks running down a white wall. The Southern scum then (1861-1865) and now (2015) are worthy of nothing but our loathing. Ditto for their fellow travelers in the ranks of the Dumbos/Teabaggers. If this is (fair & balanced) outrage at white privilege, so be it

[x MoJo]
Here's One Confederate Flag That Shouldn't Be Taken Down
By Gabrielle Canon

Tag Cloud of the following piece of writing

america apart carolina charleston clark cloth confederate cornrows course dialog discussion display exhibit explains fabric flag going hairstyles heavy help history important injustice labor legacies lives matter metaphor news people piece piles pulling racism red refer serves sits slave slow sometimes south think threads understand undo unraveling used virginia work

created at TagCrowd.com

In the wake of the tragedy in Charleston, South Carolina, one might not expect to see a Confederate battle flag solemnly hanging in the heart of New York City. But along with reflecting a history of hatred, racism, and violence, this particular flag—on display with tattered, red, white, and blue threads dangling—tells a different story.

Beside it sits the remnants of a separate flag, now reduced to red, white, and blue piles of fabric. The two pieces on display at the Mixed Greens gallery, called "Unraveling" and "Unraveled," were pulled apart by hand by artist Sonya Clark to symbolize the work needed to be done to undo the legacies of racism, prejudice, and injustice, emblemized by the flags.

"Sometimes it is really hard to undo cloth and sometimes it is a little easier," Clark tells Mother Jones. "But no matter what it is slow-going. That seemed to be a fitting metaphor for where we are. It is happening—but it is slow going. It is better now than it was—but it is slow going."

Clark, a textile artist who serves as the Department Chair of Craft and Material Studies at Virginia Commonwealth University, often tackles issues of race and identity in her work. Compelled by the news of police brutality and the Black Lives Matter movement, Clark was inspired to make a piece that would speak to both the current issues and the long history of racism in America.

Then, during a tour of the Museum of the Confederacy in Virginia, she came face to face with one of the original battle flags of the Confederacy. She took a photo of the tattered flag, capturing her own reflection in the protection glass—and it sparked an idea.

On April 9, on the 150 year anniversary of the end of the Civil War, she began pulling apart a Confederate flag. Piece-by-piece, string-by-string, she and her studio assistants undid the heavy woven fabric until it became something unrecognizable. The result, and the act of unraveling, serve as an important metaphor.

"We understand cloth in a way," she explains. "We are all wearing cloth. But we actually don’t understand how it is made. We live in the United States of America and we are used to a kind of injustice because it is part of the fabric of our nation. There’s a way in which unraveling a cloth—using that metaphor, using that sense that a material that we are so familiar with, but we don’t actually understand how it was constructed. Undoing it helps us understand that."

The fully undone flag, named "Unraveled," now reduced to piles of thread, sits next to "Unraveling," the flag that still remains mostly intact. That piece serves a related but separate purpose. It represents the collective work needed to be done to unravel racism, and the dialog that help will facilitate that work. Starting with a flag that had only partially been unwoven, 50 volunteers joined Clark in pulling apart the heavy cotton threads on opening night of the exhibit. In an hour and a half they were only able to dismantle about an inch, but Clark says the exhibit helped ignite important discussions.

"I don’t think we are going to get far in terms of undoing the deep history of racism and the legacies of prejudice and injustice without having dialog," she explains. "It allowed me to stand next to people who volunteered, to undo the flag together. One on one. So we were having conversations about the process, about our lives, about ourselves."

This isn't the first time Clark has used the divisive image to make a broader point. In 2010 she did her first Confederate-flag piece, to highlight the how the wealth of this nation was built on the backs of slave labor. Threads stitched into a confederate flag painted onto canvas, depict an overlaying American flag in cornrows and bantu knots.

"I used cornrows because they are of course African diasporic a hairstyling technique that is pretty traditional. But the cornrows themselves also refer to working the land and Bantu knots refer to a group of people that were enslaved and brought across during the transatlantic slave trade," she explains. "Even in the names of those hairstyles it refers to the people and the working of the land—the free labor that people of African descent provided."

Now, heartbroken by the news of the Charleston shooting, she hopes to expand the discussion. She already has plans for more "Unraveling" flags to give those interested the opportunity to participate.

"When I made this piece I certainly would not have foretold that there would have been people massacred in South Carolina. I am saddened of course by that fact," she says with a long pause. "But I do think that what has also happened is that, that awful tragedy has empowered this action of unraveling the confederate flag. It becomes another example of the work that we have to undo." Ω

[Gabrielle Canon is a writing fellow at Mother Jones. She has previously written for LA Weekly and the Huffington Post. Canon received both a BS (music) and an MA (journalism) from the University of Southern California.]

Copyright © 2015 Mother Jones and the Foundation for National Progress




This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License..

Copyright © 2015 Sapper's (Fair & Balanced) Rants & Raves