Late last week, Joe Nocera offered a NY Fishwrap Op-Ed essay that picked the Bay of Pigs (1961) as a metaphor for the early failure of the Affordable Care Act web site; the subtext was that JFK learned from the Bay of Pigs disaster and applied that experience to a more successful resolution of the Cuban Missile Crisis (1962) and Nocera expressed hope that the POTUS 44 would profit from JFK's example. The essay prompted 250 (mostly negative) comments from NY Fishwrap readers. One of the best was written by Rob Z of Central Massachusetts:
Yet another in an endless parade of critiques about the ACA website by people who know very little about building websites. Yes, it should function quickly and effectively, but how could Obama possibly control the design, code and performance of a website? As the owner of a advertising and marketing firm, I can assure you all websites have their unique challenges and sometimes simply do not work. Few realize you have to design a site that appears and functions identically on a variety of platforms and browsers. This particular site was huge undertaking. Yes, they should have tested the site before the launch. However, comparisons to the Bay of Pigs invasion is more than an ridiculous stretch. How about a column on how the GOP is undermining the rollout at every turn as a matter of policy? There is something seriously awry when a political party has the stated goal to fascilitate failure.
Amen, Brother Rob. If the failure of the ACA web site is our Cuban Missile Crisis, then the Dumbos/Morons are the equivalent of the Nikita Khruschev's Soviet Politburo. Delicious as the irony would be, Nikita Khruschev is a more preferable adversary than the Dumbos/Morons. He was an adversary and the Dumbos/Morons are traitors, who — though native-born — seek to destroy the government of the United States of America by "drowning it like a baby in the bathtub" (according to Grover Norquist). Final note: a brief visit to the HealthCare.gov web site produced positive results while randomly clicking on tabs and links (like "Learn what we're doing to improve HealthCare.gov"). In the meantime, the Dumbos/Morons continue to chant malevolent incantations that will bring about the impeachment and removal of the POTUS 44. If this is a (fair & balanced) illustration that history doesn't repeat itself, so be it.
[x NY Fishwrap]
Obama’s Bay Of Pigs
By Joe Nocera
Tag Cloud of the following piece of writing
Copyright © 2013 Rob Rogers/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
This week, when we are remembering John F. Kennedy, I’d like to touch briefly on the greatest fiasco of his presidency: the Bay of Pigs invasion. No sooner had Kennedy taken the oath of office than he discovered that the Pentagon and C.I.A. were preparing to send 1,500 Cuban exiles to invade Cuba. Though they would be greatly outnumbered by Cuban troops, the American military and the C.I.A. assumed that once the attack began, the Cuban people would rise up and overthrow Fidel Castro.
Kennedy was privately skeptical, but he didn’t yet have the confidence in his own judgment to override the experts he was surrounded by. So he gave the go-ahead — only to discover that the experts didn’t know what they were talking about. The exiles were quickly routed, America was humiliated and Kennedy was left to take the blame.
So far, at least, the implementation of the Affordable Care Act has been President Obama’s Bay of Pigs. Led to believe that the preparation for Obamacare was on track, Obama was blindsided when that turned out not to be the case. The website where people are supposed to enroll, HealthCare.gov, is a train wreck. People with individual policies saw that they were set to be canceled — and then couldn’t enroll in Obamacare because the website had collapsed. In other cases, people discovered that even the least expensive plan available to them under Obamacare cost more than their old plan. And on and on.
There are two primary reasons Obamacare has gotten off to such a terrible start. The first is that it is one of the most complicated things that the federal government has ever tried to do; it was inevitable that there would be problems.
An insurance executive friend says that the systems Obamacare required were an order of magnitude more complex than even the most complicated insurance company systems. That complexity, says Drew Altman, the president of the Kaiser Family Foundation, was necessitated by the many compromises that were required to pass the bill into law. Ted Marmor, a former Yale professor and an expert on entitlement programs, says that it has to coexist within the extraordinarily complicated “patchwork” that is the American health care system.
Marmor was a young special assistant in the old Department of Health, Education and Welfare when Medicare rolled out in 1966 — a rollout that was as smooth as Obamacare’s has been rocky. (“Our biggest worry was getting Southern hospitals to treat black people,” Marmor told me.) Partly that was because Medicare was a relatively straightforward program. But Marmor also believes that it was because the men in charge of the new Medicare program were seasoned pros who knew how to get the job done.
Thus the second reason the Obamacare rollout has been so awful. “They put amateurs in charge,” says Marmor. Obama would have been much better served if, for instance, he had called upon his friend Jeffrey Immelt, the chief executive of General Electric, to choose a team of specialists to lead the effort.
To even think that thought, however, requires management skills that this president has never shown. Nor has his initial reaction done much to instill faith. Calling on insurance companies to allow people to keep their old insurance plans — even after they’ve been canceled — is untenable. Even if state boards of insurance would allow such a move, it still wreaks havoc with the calculations upon which premiums are set.
Obama also announced a deadline of Nov. 30 for fixing the problems with HealthCare.gov. But what will that really accomplish? It is an arbitrary deadline that will almost surely not be met — and will sow even more mistrust.
With each day’s stories about the troubled rollout of Obamacare, it is easy to believe that it is doomed. But it’s not — not by a long shot. “We’ll know a lot more when we see what the roughly 15 million to 16 million people who are expected to get coverage that first year think,” says Altman. “And they won’t know themselves what they think about Obamacare until they start getting services.”
Jonathan Gruber, the M.I.T. economist who helped devise the Massachusetts health plan upon which Obamacare is modeled, says the deadline that matters is March 31, 2014. That’s when the individual mandate comes into play — meaning that people will either have signed up for health insurance or pay a fine. “It’s way too early to panic,” he says.
Eighteen months after the Bay of Pigs, President Kennedy was confronted with the Cuban missile crisis. Once again, the generals in the Pentagon wanted him to respond militarily, a route that was likely to lead to war with the Soviet Union. But this time, he trusted his own judgment, took a different path and defused the crisis. He had applied the lessons he had learned from the Bay of Pigs to the Cuban missile crisis.
As President Obama tries to turn Obamacare around, that is the looming question: Can he learn? Ω
[Joseph "Joe" Nocera is a business columnist and an opinion columnist for The New York Times. Nocera is also a business commentator for NPR’s Weekend Edition. Before joining the Times in 2005, Nocera held editorial positions with the Washington Monthly, Newsweek, the New England Monthly and Texas Monthly. His 1994 book, A Piece of the Action: How the Middle Class Joined the Money Class, won the New York Public Library's 1995 Helen Bernstein Award for best non-fiction book of the year. Nocera also won three Gerald Loeb Awards (1993, 1996, 2008) and three John Hancock Awards (1983, 1984, 1991). And he was a 2007 finalist for the Pulitzer Prize in Commentary. Nocera has also written Good Guys and Bad Guys: Behind the Scenes with the Saints and Scoundrels of American Business (and Everything in Between) (2008), and (with Bethany McLean) All the Devils Are Here: The Hidden History of the Financial Crisis (2010).Joe Nocera earned a B.S. in journalism from Boston University.]
Copyright © 2013 The New York Times Company
Sapper's (Fair & Balanced) Rants & Raves by Neil Sapper is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. Based on a work at sapper.blogspot.com. Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available here.
Copyright © 2013 Sapper's (Fair & Balanced) Rants & Raves
