Tuesday, November 21, 2017

Roll Over, John Adams — The Free-Speech Battles Have Been Joined Again

This blogger readily admits to a case of predator-fatigue. From the Oval Office to USO Tours to the Gadsden (AL) Mall and various media headquarters in between, the wave of predatory behavior may become a tsunami and this blogger has had enough. In a welcome item, Mary Sanchez's op-ed about free speech and the right to express disdain toward the Moron-in-Chief and the moron-voters who elected him in 2016 gave this blogger something to think about other than smarmy predators. On top of that, the issue at question in the Sanchez op-ed is a window sticker that carried two statements for the Moron-in-Chief and the moron-voters who have enabled him. Interestingly, the actor Bryan Cranston used the same epithet for critics of the Moron-in-Chief: "...For anyone who’s hoping that the commander in chief fails — “F--- you.” Well, this blogger sends the epithet right back to Cranston. Just this AM, the idiot-actor was announced to make a guest-appearance on "The Dan Patrick Show." Followed by a click on this blogger's remote. The idiot-actor is not welcome at any time within the blogger's sight or vision. Disgusting. If this a (fair & balanced) account of present-day free-speech wars, so be it.

[x KC Fishwrap]
We Must Defend Free Speech, Because Trump Won’t
By Mary Sanchez

TagCrowd cloud of the following piece of writing

created at TagCrowd.com

If Donald Trump were capable of graceful elocution, this might be how he’d phrase his feelings about those he perceives to be America’s internal enemies:

“There are citizens of the United States, I blush to admit, born under other flags but welcomed under our generous naturalization laws to the full freedom and opportunity of America, who have poured the poison of disloyalty into the very arteries of our national life.”

In fact, those words were delivered more than a century ago by another US president, Woodrow Wilson, whose views on unfaithful foreigners in our midst and on the perfidious press prefigured those of Trump. Indeed, it was Wilson who exhorted Congress to give the Justice Department greater powers to prosecute seditious speech and censor the press in the interest of “public safety.”

In 1917, Wilson signed the Espionage Act into law, and it is this constitutionally dubious legislation that some observers fear will give Trump the power he desires to harass — or, worse, legally silence — his critics in the Fourth Estate.

One expert who raises this possibility is Floyd Abrams, the First Amendment lawyer celebrated for successfully defending the New York Times’ right to publish the classified Pentagon Papers pertaining to the war in Vietnam.

Abrams has been touring the country to promote his new book, The Soul of the First Amendment (2017), and he spoke recently with The [KC] Star’s editorial board.

Abrams warned that reporters might fall under the Espionage Act microscope if the administration sees their work as in conflict with national security. After all, Trump is well-known for his assertions that the “fake news media” is “an enemy of the American people.”

Interestingly, those sentiments, often expressed in outraged tweets, might ultimately serve as a defense for journalists, as they show Trump’s pattern of extreme personal sensitivity to any criticism at all. It would not be difficult to demonstrate that any clampdown had less to do with public safety than with Trump’s ego.

And then there’s the ink, which the press buys by the barrel as the saying goes. It can also afford the best legal counsel, such as Abrams.

But what about the legions of aspiring mini-Trumps, the elected officials major and minor across the land who observe the president flout the rule of law and regard it as a green light for their own authoritarian tendencies?

Texas offers a chilling example this week in the actions of Fort Bend County Sheriff Troy E. Nehls. The sheriff was outraged by reports of a pickup truck seen around this suburban hinterland of Houston, the wealthiest county in Texas, with a sticker on its rear window reading, “F--- Trump and f--- you for voting for him.”

Nehls posted a picture of the truck on a personal Facebook page [see illustration above], bragging that a county prosecutor had agreed to charge the truck’s owner with disorderly conduct. That created an avalanche of publicity, and the Republican county prosecutor denied that the case would be prosecutable. Nehls deleted the post, but a woman who shares the truck with her husband was arrested — not for the sticker but for an unrelated outstanding warrant. The American Civil Liberties Union has offered her help.

Did I mention that Nehls is pondering a run for Congress?

The national mood is such Nehls’ little escapade got shut down pretty quickly. But you have to wonder about other instances where someone’s First Amendment rights will be trampled because the Mayberry Machiavelli doing the trampling isn’t so brazen and stupid about it.

This is exactly why, as Abrams says, the public needs to reaffirm both its understanding of and respect for the First Amendment. As in the Vietnam War era, those in political power will appeal to national security to evade scrutiny, criticism and exposure.

Yet, increasingly, all of us struggle to find the balance between the right of fellow citizens to express vile views and the legitimate concern for public safety and the rights of individuals to be safe from threats to their personal safety. Remember the white supremacists who descended on Charlottesville, VA, to assert their race hatred? One of them ended up murdering a counter-demonstrator, and others committed lesser acts of violence and intimidation.

We live in interesting times [according to the ancient Chinese curse]. Too many people — from Trump to sheriffs to possibly your neighbor — believe it’s legitimate to outlaw or suppress expression contrary to their own views.

That’s un-American, if anything is. You may find it offensive. You may find it personally insulting. But protected speech must remain protected, or the America we love will cease to be. # # #

[Mary Sanchez is a KC-native who is an editorial columnist for The Kansas City Star. Sanchez received a BS (education) from Northwest Missouri State University.]

Copyright © 2017 The Kansas City Star

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License..

Copyright © 2017 Sapper's (Fair & Balanced) Rants & Raves

No comments:

Post a Comment

☛ STOP!!! Read the following BEFORE posting a Comment!

Include your e-mail address with your comment or your comment will be deleted by default. Your e-mail address will be DELETED before the comment is posted to this blog. Comments to entries in this blog are moderated by the blogger. Violators of this rule can KMA (Kiss My A-Double-Crooked-Letter) as this blogger's late maternal grandmother would say. No e-mail address (to be verified AND then deleted by the blogger) within the comment, no posting. That is the (fair & balanced) rule for comments to this blog.